Why Choose? (Audio Script)

Stories

“Another glass of this ultra-rare Dom Perignon?”

“I’m pacing myself. That’s like five grand a bottle!”

“A complimentary five grand bottle, they said.”

I pick up the card that came with the champagne and ice bucket, running my thumb over the hotel logo embossed in silver.

“On behalf of the Amantes Hotel, we extend our warmest congratulations on your tenth wedding anniversary.

Please enjoy a bottle of our finest champagne, compliments of the hotel manager.”

“Along with the upgrade to our top-floor penthouse.”

“Yeah, I thought the Executive Suite was something.

This is gorgeous.”

I pour myself my second glass of champagne and sip.

The bubbles coat my tongue as it slides down my throat, warming my belly.

I thought another glass might quell my nerves, but it’s only making me more excited.

I bounce on the arches of my feet, one to the other, as you check out the settings on the mirror TV.

You and your gadgets.

And in your his-and-hers hotel robe and slippers, of course.

We’re not really the bougie type for anniversaries.

Most years, our favourite Chinese takeout and a movie night with a few little gifts is good enough for us.

Other times, we opt for a relaxed day out where we grab breakfast at that cozy little cafe we love, and head out to the countryside.

But this is a milestone, and we wanted to mark the occasion in a more memorable way.

And…mark the occasion we are.

“You’re pacing again.”

“I knoooww…I just…I have all this energy, and I just need to expel it.

See, this is why I like surprises. I don’t have time to get nervous!

”

You get off the bed and come over to me, taking my hand in yours.

“It’s going to be okay.

I mean, I could have surprised you, but…two guys suddenly showing up on your wedding anniversary without talking about it first…?”

“Yeah, true…”

“Yeah, it feels like a pretty risky way to start our anniversary night.”

You give me a reassuring squeeze, but I can feel the way your hands shake a little. You’re nervous too, but still you’re trying to make me feel better.

“Come on, shake it out.

Shhaaakkke it out.

”

“Okay, okay…”

I shake out my shoulders and stretch out my neck.

You give my hands another reassuring squeeze, and I feel more at ease. The feel of your big, warm hands around mine grounds me.

You always know what to do to calm me down. It was one of the things that drew me to you when we first met.

“It’s going to be okay.

And if you change your mind...or you want to slow down…all you have to do is say the word, okay?

”

“I know, and thanks.

I’m not changing my mind, I’m just…

I don’t know, I just don’t know what to do with all this energy until they get here.

”

The corners of your lips quirk up, and you playfully waggle your eyebrows.

Of course, you’d turn it sexy.

And it is our anniversary…and we are in a swanky hotel penthouse waiting for two other guys to show up, sooo…I can’t exactly blame you.

You wrap your arms around my waist and lean in a little closer.

Your breath tickles my lips, and I feel heat rise in my cheeks, a giddy smile spreading across my face.

“I can think of a way to get that energy out…”

“Oh yeah?

How?

”

“I can think of a few.

But I think this is the best…”

Your lips press to mine, sensual but with a firmness that sends a current of heat up my body.

You want me…and I want you.

And while I know tonight is about trying something new, it’s still our wedding anniversary.

We can have a little “husband and wife time” until Jake and his friend arrive.

Your hands roam over my back through my robe, one up my spine and the other down to my ass, giving it a deliberate squeeze.

“I want you…”

You slip your palms over my breasts as you trail hungry kisses down my neck, and I arch into you, pressing myself into your touch.

A hot shiver runs down my spine as we untie each other’s robes, letting them fall to the ground.

“Come here…”

We tumble back onto the bed and I pull you on top of me.

My body’s on display for you, and I watch as you dip your head, your tongue tracing between my breasts as you palm them before giving each a soft squeeze.

“Ahh…”

“God, you’re so sexy…”

You hook your arms around my legs and gently press them apart as you continue kissing along my ribs, down my stomach…

Until I can feel the teasing touch of your lips along my inner thigh…

I thread my fingers into your hair, need coursing through me as you move your mouth slowly closer…

Closer to right between my legs.

Fuck…

“Yeah…right there…”

“Yeah…?

You’re my girl?

”

“Yeah…”

We freeze, both our heads snapping up in unison to look at the door.

Excitement tingles in my belly.

They’re here.

“You ready?”

“Hey, come in.”

Jake comes in, and as promised, he’s brought a friend.

Jake’s been your best friend since you finished university. While you wanted to settle down, he’s the “chronic bachelor” type.

So when we talked about this little fantasy, we knew exactly which “try anything once” person to ask.

And he knew who to ask to be our fourth.

I feel a little exposed, being naked on the bed with my legs spread as two other men come inside.

But it’s a good exposed…like an amuse bouche of what’s to come as Jake’s eyes wander over my body, and his eyes darken with lust.

“Hey Jake…”

“Hey, you.

Getting the party started without us, huh?

”

His friend is…wow, he’s gorgeous. He’s blond, and his blue eyes pierce straight into mine.

My skin prickles and heats up as they slide down my body, and his teeth swiftly flick over his bottom lip.

“He was just getting me warmed up.

Who’s your friend?

”

I look at Jake, then you as you join me on the bed, placing soft little kisses along my shoulder.

I can’t help the grin that spreads across my face, even as my gaze once again finds the stranger behind you both.

“Oooh. Jake, I like him.”

“Thanks.”

Blue Eyes keeps his eyes on me, watching as he unbuttons his shirt.

Jake slips his shirt off behind me, before moving closer so he can bury his face in my neck.

“Fuck…”

The heat of his mouth as he leans over me feels incredible. My gaze locks with Blue Eyes, and I hold out my hand.

“Are you coming over? Or are you just going to stand there looking cute?”

The corners of his lips turn up and he makes quick work of his belt.

“I wanted you to get a good view.”

You palm over my breasts, taking one into your mouth and flicking your tongue over my chest as Jake finally joins us on the bed.

“Ohh…”

I’m caught in a tangle of bodies and hungry gazes.

Their hands, their lips…

Jake kisses along the nape of my neck, his hands trailing down the dip of my waist and back up to my ribs, just below my breasts.

Blue Eyes kicks off his jeans, stroking his palm over the bulge in his boxers while Jake gently brushes my hair from my neck.

“So beautiful…”

“On all fours, babe…

I want to watch for a while…

”

You shift further up the bed, sitting up so you can lean back and stroke your cock as Jake shifts further down the bed as he starts…